870 pages in 25 hours (including a good night's sleep). Not too shabby.
Enjoyed the book, but it just didn't seem quite as fun as the last few. Maybe because I knew the plot line, maybe because of too much hype, maybe because I'm no fun.
Here's a quick review I wrote to Kirsty (no spoilers!):
A couple things that kept driving me nuts: I'm used to the American versions, and it seems like past editors have done a little more to translate British colloquialisms into American ones, but not in this volume. Ron kept saying "mate," which kept bugging me, and people were getting "into a row," which we don't say over here. I wouldn't have minded it, had the other books been like this, but seeing as though the first four books were "Americanized," the fact that this was wasn't kept bothering me. I assume you didn't have that problem? :>
Maybe I'm just too used to Rowling's style and the Harry Potter plot scheme, but I felt like I kind of knew the progression of the book a little too much. This one was a little more different, which was nice, but still, it seemed like once we got to Hogwarts, it was "Talk about Harry's classes, describe a Quidditch match, talk some more about classes, Ron and Hermione fight, Snape yells at Neville, Ron and Harry fight, Christmas time, more classes, a Hagrid story, big dramatic ending that leaves you wanting more and reveals the foreshadowing at the beginning of the book."
I felt like there were several chapters that were there only to allow some plot catch later in the book, and I wonder if they could have been introduced without a whole couple of chapters at St. Mungo's, or Grawp, or whatever.
I really enjoyed the book--couldn't put it down, in fact--and some of the chapters (the last four, as well as some others here and there) were really exciting and fun, but something just didn't feel right about the ending. Kind of anti-climatic.
Recent Comments